The city of Decatur, Alabama, is reeling after a tragic shooting on Thursday night that claimed the life of Dontay Jamar Garner. The heartbreaking incident has left family, friends, and the community mourning the loss of a man remembered for his loyalty, kindness, and bright spirit.
Tragic Shooting at 5th Avenue Food Mart
According to the Decatur Police Department, officers responded to reports of a shooting at the 5th Avenue Food Mart around 6:30 p.m. on October 30, 2025. When authorities arrived, they discovered Dontay Jamar Garner suffering from a gunshot wound. Despite immediate lifesaving efforts, Morgan County Coroner Jeff Chunn pronounced Garner dead at the scene.
Suspect Arrested at the Scene
Following a swift investigation, detectives identified Xavier Rashawn Sutherlin as the suspect in the fatal shooting. Authorities confirmed that Sutherlin remained at the scene when officers arrived and was taken into custody without incident. He has since been charged with Murder and booked into the Morgan County Jail, where he is being held without bond.
At this time, investigators have not disclosed what led to the deadly confrontation or whether the two men knew one another. The Decatur Police Department’s Violent Crimes Unit continues to investigate the case, urging anyone with additional information to contact Decatur Police or Morgan County Crime Stoppers.
Remembering Dontay Jamar Garner
The loss of Dontay Garner has left a deep wound in the Decatur community. Those who knew him describe him as a kindhearted and dependable person whose smile could lift the spirits of those around him. Friends and loved ones remember him not only for his loyalty and generosity but also for his ability to bring light to any room he entered.
As news of his passing spreads, the community continues to rally around Garner’s family, offering prayers, love, and support during this unimaginable time of loss.
A Reminder of the Cost of Violence
This senseless act of violence serves as another painful reminder of the toll that gun violence takes on families and communities across Alabama. As investigators seek answers, the people of Decatur mourn the life of Dontay Jamar Garner, a man whose memory will live on in the hearts of those who loved him.